Cheeky Bites

Recipes, guides and kitchen know-how. Mostly useful, occasionally silly.

Updated 14 min read

Buttermilk Chicken - Soak It Overnight, Fry It Crisp, Cook It Right Through

In short

Boneless thighs soaked overnight in spiced buttermilk, pressed into a craggy flour and cornflour coat and fried at 175C until 75C in the middle. A buttermilk chicken recipe with oven, air fryer, burger and tender versions.

Golden fried chicken on a wooden board, chilli Oliver holding up a crispy piece, toast Erin pointing, Doberman Tyson peeking

Rate this recipe

  • Prep20 min
  • Soak4-24 hr
  • Cook30 min
  • Serves4
  • Calories~590

Calories are approximate, per serving, worked out from the ingredients. Brands and portion sizes vary. That includes the oil the coating soaks up. It does not include the dip. The dip is your business.

This buttermilk chicken is 1kg of boneless thighs soaked overnight in 300ml of salted, spiced buttermilk, pressed into a craggy flour-and-cornflour coat and fried at 175C until it's golden outside and 75C in the middle. Serves four, or two people and a Doberman who has learned how fridge doors work.

Most of the work happens while you're asleep. Which is my favourite kind of work. I've been training for it for years.

The whole trick is the soak. The buttermilk makes the meat tender and gives the flour something sticky to cling to. No soak, no crunch. That's not a recipe, that's a chicken with a dusting problem.

There's an oven and air fryer version further down for anyone who'd rather not stand over a pan of hot oil. Eesha. I mean Eesha.

Where does fried chicken in buttermilk come from?

Southern fried chicken in a cast iron pan, jalapeño Lara holding a drumstick and an egg, onion Ayden reading an old cookbook
Lara asked which came first. She was holding both. Ayden is still reading out the answer.

Fried chicken as we know it comes from the American South, where enslaved African cooks turned plain flour-and-lard frying into the seasoned, crunchy dish it is today.

The first printed American recipe turns up in an 1820s cookbook: chicken dredged in flour, salted and fried in lard. Smithsonian Magazine tells the story of that first recipe, and of the women who sold fried chicken to hungry train passengers through the carriage windows.

The buttermilk soak came later, and Southern cooks have argued about it ever since. Some brine first, some don't, some say it's lard or nothing. It's the only argument in our house louder than who gets the crispy bits.

Ayden read the whole history out loud. At the table. While we were eating. Fowl play, if you ask me.

Ingredients

The soak is chicken thighs, buttermilk, salt and a few spices. Serves 4.

  • 1kg skinless chicken thighs
  • Boneless, about 8
  • Thighs stay juicy where breast dries out
  • Breast works. Then you chew for a fortnight.
  • 300ml buttermilk - shop-bought is easiest
  • Or sour a jug of milk with a lemon instead
  • 2 tsp fine salt - no more
  • It soaks all night. Too much turns it hammy
  • 1 tsp garlic powder, 1 tsp paprika
  • ½ tsp black pepper
  • Plus 1 tbsp hot sauce if you like a kick
Fried chicken ingredients of chicken thighs, buttermilk, salt and paprika, pizza slice Isaac hugging the paprika, black dog Dexter

Isaac claimed the paprika. It's red. Those are the rules. Dexter claimed the chicken. Nobody agreed to that.

For the crunchy coating

The coating is plain flour, cornflour, baking powder, spices and salt, plus oil to fry in.

  • 200g plain flour and 50g cornflour
  • Cornflour makes it shatter, not chew
  • 1 tsp baking powder
  • Tiny bubbles in the coat, lighter crunch
  • 2 tsp smoked paprika, 2 tsp garlic powder
  • 1 tsp onion powder, 1 tsp black pepper
  • ½-1 tsp cayenne, 1 tsp dried thyme
  • 1 tsp salt
  • About 1.5 litres oil for frying
  • Sunflower, vegetable or groundnut
  • Not olive - it smokes before it's hot enough
Seasoned flour and cornflour coating in a bowl, garlic Eesha with a clipboard, jacket potato Aaron covered in flour

Aaron opened the cornflour like it owed him money. Eesha gave him a detention. He's still floured.

This is where the crunch lives. Get the seasoning into the flour, not just the soak.

Kit

Kitchen scissors, probe thermometer, deep pan and wire rack, jacket potato Aaron with a checklist, chilli Oliver adding a thermometer
Aaron brought one thermometer. I added a second. He checked them against each other. For forty minutes.
  • Kitchen scissors for trimming the fat and halving big thighs. We use a sturdy pair of kitchen scissors - much easier than a knife on slippery raw chicken, and they come apart for a proper wash
  • A thermometer - one for the oil, and a digital probe for the middle of the chicken. The probe does both if you're careful
  • A deep, heavy pan - wide enough for 3 or 4 pieces, deep enough that the oil only comes a third of the way up
  • A slotted spoon or tongs, plus a wire rack on a baking tray - one for the coated raw pieces, one for the cooked ones

Buttermilk fried chicken, step by step

Step 1 - Trim it and soak it the night before

Step 1, chicken thighs trimmed with kitchen scissors into a bowl of buttermilk, chilli Oliver snipping, toast Erin at the fridge
Erin held the fridge door open and issued a royal decree. The decree was: hurry up. The chicken obeyed.
  1. Trim any big lumps of fat with the scissors and cut very large thighs in half, so every piece is roughly the same size and cooks in the same time.
  2. Whisk the buttermilk, salt, garlic powder, paprika, pepper and hot sauce in a big bowl or lidded tub.
  3. Add the chicken, turn it so every piece is coated, put the lid on and straight into the fridge for at least 4 hours - overnight is best, 24 hours is the limit.

The single most important thing: soak it overnight, in the fridge. Four hours works. Overnight is noticeably juicier and better seasoned. Past 24 hours the salt starts to make it hammy and the texture goes soft. And don't rinse the raw chicken first - the Food Standards Agency says washing chicken just splashes germs round your sink. The bugs die in the pan, not under the tap.

Step 2 - Make the coating craggy

Step 2, buttermilk drizzled into seasoned flour to make crumbs, pizza slice Isaac in a bowl helmet, Doberman Tyson with a spoon
Isaac wore the spare bowl as a helmet. Tyson took the wooden spoon. Nobody's sure which of them is the villain.
  1. Whisk the flour, cornflour, baking powder, spices and salt together in a wide bowl.
  2. Take 3 tablespoons of the buttermilk from the soaking bowl and drizzle it over the flour.
  3. Rub it in with your fingertips until you've got little pea-sized clumps through the flour. Those clumps are your crunch.

It looks like you've ruined the flour. You haven't. That's the craggy bit everyone fights over. Batter late than never.

Step 3 - Coat it, press it, rest it on a rack

Step 3, coated chicken pieces on a wire rack, jalapeño Lara pressing chicken into flour, onion Ayden covered in flour
Lara coated the chicken. Then she coated Ayden. She says he was in the way. He was not in the way.
  1. Lift a piece out of the buttermilk and let the extra drip off for a few seconds - too much and the coat slides off in the oil.
  2. Drop it in the flour, pile more on top and press it on firmly with your palm. Turn it and press again.
  3. Lay it on the wire rack. Do the rest, then fry within about 10 minutes - long enough for the coat to set, not so long it goes soggy.

Keep one hand for the wet chicken and one for the flour. Otherwise you end up with breaded fingers. Ask Ayden.

Step 4 - Fry at 175C, a few pieces at a time

Step 4, chicken frying in a deep pan of oil with a probe thermometer, jacket potato Aaron in goggles, garlic Eesha standing back
Aaron wore safety goggles. Eesha stood well back. The chicken was the calmest one in the kitchen.
  1. Pour oil into the deep pan to about 5cm deep - never more than a third full. Heat it to 175C.
  2. Lower in 3 or 4 pieces, away from you. Don't touch them for 2 minutes so the coat can set.
  3. Fry for 6 to 8 minutes, turning once, until deep golden. Keep the oil between 170C and 180C - it drops when the chicken goes in.

Never leave hot oil alone, and keep the lid nearby. If it catches fire, don't throw water on it - turn the heat off only if it's safe, get out and call 999. South Yorkshire Fire and Rescue's hot oil advice is worth a read before you start.

Step 5 - Check it's 75C, then drain it on a rack

Step 5, golden fried chicken on a rack with a probe reading 75, chilli Oliver giving a thumbs up, black dog Dexter leaning in
75C. Thumbs up. Dexter leaned on my legs to say well done. Also to say he'd noticed lunch.
  1. Push the probe into the thickest piece. You want 75C in the middle - here's where to put the probe so it isn't lying to you. No probe? Cut the biggest piece open: no pink, juices clear, steaming hot.
  2. Lift it onto the clean wire rack, not kitchen paper. Paper traps steam and steam is the enemy of crunch.
  3. Sprinkle with a pinch of salt and keep warm in an 80C oven while you fry the rest.

A thigh-five for anyone who used the rack. A soggy bottom for anyone who used a plate.

In the oven or the air fryer instead

Crispy coated chicken in an air fryer and on an oven tray, toast Erin pressing the air fryer button, pizza slice Isaac with tongs
Erin pressed the button like she was launching a ship. Isaac did the actual cooking. As usual.

Same soak, same coat - you just swap the pan of oil for a hot oven or an air fryer. It's a bit less crunchy, a lot less faff and nobody needs goggles.

  • Oven: heat to 200C (180C fan). Lay the coated pieces on a wire rack over a tray, spray them well with oil and bake 25 to 30 minutes, turning once, until 75C in the middle. Fan and gas numbers are on our oven chart
  • Air fryer: preheat to 200C. One layer, not touching, sprayed with real oil (not the low-calorie stuff - it just goes dusty). Cook 15 to 18 minutes, turning and spraying again halfway. Check 75C with the probe

The oil is what turns flour into crunch. No oil, no crunch, just a very well-seasoned chicken in a flour coat.

Buttermilk chicken burger

Buttermilk chicken burger in a brioche bun with slaw and gherkins, jalapeño Lara adding hot sauce, chilli Oliver sweating
Lara added the hot sauce. All of it. I'm a chilli and I was sweating. She asked for more.

One big fried thigh in a toasted brioche bun is the best burger you'll make all year. Use one whole thigh per bun, flattened a little so it cooks evenly.

  • 4 brioche buns, split and toasted
  • Chipotle mayo: 6 tbsp mayonnaise stirred with 1 tbsp chipotle paste or hot sauce
  • Shredded iceberg on the bottom bun, then the chicken, gherkins and a spoon of slaw on top

Prefer beef? The one we squash flat in a hot pan is right here. Lara has already asked for hot sauce on that too.

Why a buttermilk chicken marinade makes it tender

Chicken soaking in buttermilk with a whiteboard doodle, garlic Eesha teaching with a pointer, onion Ayden taking notes
Eesha explained the science. Ayden took notes. There's a test on Friday. There's always a test on Friday.

Buttermilk is mildly acidic, and that gentle acid loosens the proteins in the meat so it holds on to more of its juice when it cooks. A strong acid like lemon or vinegar on its own goes too far and turns the outside mushy - buttermilk is mild enough to soak all night.

Popular Science explains why dairy marinades tenderise so well - and why they only work on the outer layer, which is why smaller pieces and a long soak win.

How long to marinate chicken in buttermilk? At least 4 hours, ideally overnight, and no more than 24. Aaron set an alarm for every hour. He soaked better than the chicken.

The soak also gives the flour something to grab. Dry chicken, dry flour, nothing sticks. It's like trying to make friends at a funeral.

The fried chicken cheat sheet

Here's the whole thing on one chart - the soak, the coat, the oil temperature, the 75C check and the oven and air fryer timings. Save it, print it or stick it on the fridge. Next to the chicken. Where Dexter can read it.

Fried chicken cheat sheet - overnight soak, craggy coating, 175C oil, 75C check and oven and air fryer times, with the Cheeky Bites
Isaac checked the numbers. Aaron checked Isaac. Erin signed it off. With a tiara.
Pinch this chart

Bloggers, schools and cookery clubs: you're welcome to put this chart on your site, as long as you credit us and link back to this page. Copy the code below and paste it into your page. Tyson pinched a drumstick. He didn't credit anyone either.

Buttermilk chicken tenders, and a meat-free swap

Buttermilk chicken tenders with a dip and crispy cauliflower, pizza slice Isaac holding a tender like a sword, jacket potato Aaron
Isaac used a tender as a sword. Aaron measured the cauliflower. Both of them won, apparently.
  • Tenders: cut chicken breast into strips about 2cm thick with the scissors. Soak 2 to 12 hours, coat the same way and fry for 4 to 5 minutes, still to 75C. Breast is fine here. It's thin. It doesn't have time to sulk.
  • Meat-free: cauliflower florets or thick slices of firm tofu take the same soak (an hour is plenty) and the same coat. Fry 4 to 5 minutes until golden, or bake at 200C for 20 to 25
  • Gluten free: swap the plain flour for a gluten free blend and check your baking powder and spice mixes are gluten free too

If it goes wrong

A pale soggy piece of fried chicken losing its coating, onion Ayden holding it up, Doberman Tyson running off with a crispy one
Ayden got the soggy one. Tyson got the good one. Tyson always gets the good one.

Coating slid off in the oil? Too much buttermilk was left on, it wasn't pressed on hard enough, or it got poked too early.

Fix: Let each piece drip, press the flour on with your palm, and leave it alone for the first 2 minutes in the oil. Coat of many failures. We've all worn it.

Soggy and greasy? The oil was too cool, the pan was crowded, or it drained on kitchen paper.

Fix: Keep the oil between 170C and 180C, fry 3 or 4 pieces at a time and drain on a wire rack. Crisp is a temperature, not a personality.

Burnt outside, raw in the middle? The oil was too hot or the pieces were too thick.

Fix: Fry at 175C, halve the big thighs, and if the outside's done first, finish them on a rack in a 180C oven until the middle hits 75C. Tanned outside, panicking inside. Like me on holiday.

Tastes of nothing? All the seasoning went in the soak and none in the flour.

Fix: Season the flour properly and add a pinch of salt the second it comes out of the oil. Flavour goes in every layer. Ayden says that's the onion way.

Too salty? It soaked too long, or the salt was doubled up somewhere.

Fix: Stick to 2 tsp of fine salt in the soak and pull it out by 24 hours. It's chicken. It doesn't want to be a ham when it grows up.

Dry and tough? It was breast meat, or it cooked well past 75C.

Fix: Use thighs, probe the thickest piece and lift it out as soon as it reads 75C. Nobody wants to chew on a decision.

Fried chicken questions people actually ask

Leftover fried chicken in a lidded tub in the fridge, toast Erin putting it away, black dog Dexter watching politely
Erin put the leftovers away like the crown jewels. Dexter is guarding them. From the outside. For now.

Can you freeze fried chicken?

Yes - cool it on a rack, then freeze it in a bag for up to 3 months. Reheat from frozen on a rack in a 200C oven for 20 to 25 minutes until it's steaming hot right through. It's not as crunchy as fresh. Nothing is. Including me.

How do you reheat fried chicken?

On a rack in a 200C oven for 10 to 15 minutes, or in the air fryer at 200C for 5 to 8 minutes, until it's steaming hot in the middle. The microwave makes it soft. Leftovers go in the fridge within 2 hours - here's how long the leftovers keep, and how to warm them up. Erin has a royal claim on the leftovers. It is not negotiable.

Can you reuse the buttermilk marinade?

No - it's had raw chicken in it, so it goes in the bin. The 3 tablespoons you rub into the flour are fine because they get fried. Tyson disagrees. Tyson is wrong.

Can you use chicken breast instead of thighs?

Yes, but cut it into thinner pieces or tenders, because a thick breast dries out before the middle is done. Thighs are more forgiving. Thighs. The forgiving cut. Like a stretchy waistband.

What's the best oil for fried chicken?

A neutral oil that copes with high heat: sunflower, vegetable, rapeseed or groundnut. Lard is traditional in the American South and tastes great, but it's heavier. Not olive oil - it smokes too early. Let used oil cool completely before you strain or bin it. Never down the sink. The plumber has opinions.

What if I haven't got buttermilk?

Stir 1 tbsp lemon juice into 300ml milk and leave it 5 minutes, or thin plain yoghurt with milk to the same thickness. Both do the same job. Eesha's done it so often she doesn't measure. Don't tell her I said that.

For a whole bird instead of pieces, try a whole bird flattened with the same scissors. Different chicken. Same scissors. Same dog, sadly.

Now go and wing it. Then check it's 75C.

Pass it on

Know a kitchen that needs this? We won't say who sent it.