Recipes, guides and kitchen know-how. Mostly useful, occasionally silly.
How to Make Buttermilk - Five Minutes, One Lemon, No Cow Required
Buttermilk in 10 minutes from milk and lemon juice, what the real stuff is, four swaps if you have no lemon, freezing it, and fluffy scones to use it up.
Rate this recipe
- Prep2 min
- Rest10 min
- CookNone
- Makes250ml
- Calories~60
Calories are approximate, per 100ml, worked out from the ingredients. Brands and portion sizes vary.
Stir 1 tablespoon of lemon juice (or white vinegar) into 250ml of milk, leave it for 10 minutes, and you've got buttermilk. Near enough. Close enough for scones, anyway.
That's the whole trick. I've written two thousand words about it anyway. You're welcome.
It started on a Sunday. Scones were promised. The recipe said buttermilk. The fridge said no.
The fridge has never once said yes to anything I actually needed.
Aaron offered to drive to the big Tesco. Erin issued a royal decree that nobody leaves the house until there are scones. Her Majesty was not in the mood to be kept waiting. Her Majesty had already laid the table.
So we made our own. Milk, lemon, a jug, ten minutes. The scones rose like they'd been told there was a prize.
I read through a stack of methods before writing this one up - British dairies, food magazines, food scientists and a couple of American bakers who use the stuff like water - and kept what they all agree on. One tablespoon of acid to every 250ml of milk, and ten minutes of patience. The patience is the hard bit. Ask Aaron.
What is buttermilk?
Buttermilk is a slightly thick, tangy, soured milk - originally the thin liquid left behind after churning cream into butter.
It's basically milk that's been through something. Haven't we all.
The old-fashioned kind is the watery bit that runs off when cream finally gives up and turns into butter. On farms, nothing was wasted, so it went into bread, scones and the pig.
The stuff in supermarket cartons today is different. It's fresh low-fat milk with friendly lactic-acid bacteria added, left to sour and thicken for half a day or so. Fine Dining Lovers has a good plain-English explainer on both kinds.
Either way, the important bit is the acid. The bacteria turn the milk sugar into lactic acid, which drops milk from about pH 6.7 to roughly pH 4.5. Science ABC walks through the chemistry if you fancy it.
That acid does two jobs in baking. It reacts with bicarbonate of soda to make bubbles, so things rise. And it softens gluten, so scones come out tender instead of like something you'd use to wedge a door. Isaac explained this to me without looking up from his comic. I nodded like I already knew.
So the 5-minute fake works because it copies the bit that matters - the sourness. It doesn't copy the flavour exactly, and it won't be as thick. For baking, nobody can tell. Erin can tell. Erin can always tell. Erin ate four.
What you need

Two ingredients and a jug. That's it.
- 250ml milk - whole is best (thicker result), but semi-skimmed works
- 1 tbsp lemon juice (about half a lemon) or 1 tbsp white vinegar
- A measuring jug and a tablespoon
- Something to stir with - a whisk that cleans the jug corners on the way round, or a fork
Lara asked if that was really everything. It is. She was disappointed. She wanted a cauldron.
How to make buttermilk
Step 1 - Put the lemon juice in the jug first

Measure 1 tablespoon (15ml) of lemon juice or white vinegar into an empty measuring jug.
- Squeeze half a lemon through your fingers (they're a free sieve) into a tablespoon, then tip it into the jug.
- No lemon? White vinegar or cider vinegar does exactly the same job. Not malt - unless you want scones that smell like a chip shop.
Acid first, milk second, so it mixes in as you pour. Ayden did the face for everyone. He's an actor. He committed.
Step 2 - Top it up with milk and stir

Pour milk on top of the lemon juice up to the 250ml line, then give it a quick stir.
- Milk at room temperature curdles faster than fridge-cold milk. Five minutes out of the fridge is plenty.
- Stir once or twice. That's it. Don't whisk it hard - you're not making a milkshake.
I poured. Eesha watched the line like it owed her homework.
Step 3 - Leave it alone for 10 minutes

Leave the jug on the side for 10 minutes, until the milk looks slightly thicker and has small curdled specks.
- Tilt the jug. It should coat the side a little and have tiny white flecks. That's the acid working.
- Stir again and use it exactly like shop buttermilk, one for one, in any recipe.
Not many specks? It still works. The acid is in there either way, and that's what the bicarb needs. The specks are for show. Like Aaron's stopwatch.
The ratio is the whole recipe: 1 tablespoon of acid to every 250ml of milk. Every method I read agrees within a teaspoon. Need 150ml for scones? Use 2 teaspoons of lemon juice and top up to 150ml. Need 500ml? Double both. Maths. On a Sunday. Eesha would be proud. Eesha is never proud.
Buttermilk substitute: four more ways to fake it

The best buttermilk substitute is natural yoghurt thinned with milk - it's thicker and tangier than lemon-and-milk, and closest to the real thing.
No lemon, no vinegar, no problem. Probably.
- Yoghurt and milk: 3 parts plain natural yoghurt to 1 part milk (about 190g yoghurt + 60ml milk for 250ml). Not Greek - too thick. Best for pancakes and cakes.
- Kefir: plain kefir swaps in one for one. It's already cultured and sour. It's basically buttermilk that went to university.
- Cream of tartar: stir 1¾ tsp into a splash of milk to make a paste, then whisk in the rest up to 250ml. Lumps otherwise.
- Dairy-free: 1 tbsp lemon juice topped up to 250ml with soya or oat milk. Soya curdles best. It's thinner, so hold back a splash of liquid in the recipe.
Soured cream let down with a little water (3 to 1) works too, if that's what's lurking in the fridge. Check the date first. There's sour, and there's sour.
Isaac got all four right. Eesha gave him a gold star and a suspicious look.
Real buttermilk: the stuff left after making butter
Real, old-style buttermilk is the thin liquid that drains off when you whisk cream until it splits into butter.
We did exactly that in the leftovers you get from churning a pot of double cream post. A 600ml pot gives you about 300g of butter and roughly 250ml of buttermilk. Two products for the price of one. Very Yorkshire. We're not from Yorkshire.
That buttermilk is thinner than the carton kind and only lightly sour, because supermarket cream isn't soured first. It's still lovely in scones and pancakes. Keep it in the fridge and use it within 2 or 3 days.
Want something closer to the thick shop version? Stir 2 tablespoons of shop-bought buttermilk into 500ml of whole milk, cover it, and leave it somewhere warm for 12 to 24 hours until it's thickened. Then chill it. Keep back a splash and you can start the next batch with it. It's like a sourdough starter, but it doesn't need a name or emotional support.
Aaron, being from Belfast, says his granny drank buttermilk by the glass with her dinner. He says it like a threat.
Buttermilk scones - the reason we started

These scones need 225g self-raising flour, 50g cold butter, 150ml buttermilk and 12 to 15 minutes at 220C (200C fan). Makes about 8.
Buttermilk makes them taller and softer. Taller than Aaron, some of them.
- 225g self-raising flour, plus extra for dusting
- 1 tsp baking powder and a pinch of salt
- 50g cold butter, cubed
- 25g caster sugar (leave it out for cheese scones)
- 150ml buttermilk (2 tsp lemon juice topped up to 150ml with milk), plus a splash to brush the tops
- Jam and clotted cream to serve. Order of application to be decided by civil war.
- Heat the oven to 220C (200C fan), gas 7. Line a baking tray.
- Mix the flour, baking powder and salt in a bowl. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until it looks like breadcrumbs. Stir in the sugar.
- Make a well, pour in the buttermilk and mix with a knife until it just comes together into a soft, slightly sticky dough. Add a splash more milk if it's dry.
- Tip onto a floured worktop and knead it twice. Twice. Then roll it gently to about 2.5cm thick. Take the rings off a stainless steel pin that doesn't stick to soft dough - scones want more height than the thickest ring gives you.
- Cut out rounds with a 6cm cutter. Push straight down, don't twist - twisting seals the sides and they rise lopsided. Squish the scraps together and cut again.
- Brush the tops with buttermilk and bake for 12 to 15 minutes, until risen and golden. Cool on a rack for 10 minutes. Five, if Erin's about.
Same pin that rolled out the gingerbread army that kept its legs on. It's had a busy autumn.
Buttermilk recipe ideas: put the rest of the jug to work
Buttermilk goes in soda bread, pancakes, scones, cakes, fried chicken marinades and creamy dressings - anything that needs a lift or a tender crumb.
- Soda bread - no yeast, no kneading, on the table in under an hour. Here's the loaf Aaron won the argument with. Aaron's specialist subject. Don't get him started. Too late.
- Pancakes - thick, fluffy American-style ones. The acid plus bicarb is what makes them puff. Here's the stack that doesn't lean. Dexter has his eye on the bottom one.
- Chicken - soak it overnight before frying or baking. The acid tenderises the meat and helps the coating stick. Here's the crunchy thighs we fry at 175C. Tyson has already found it.
- Cakes and muffins - swap it for milk in a chocolate cake for a softer, damper crumb.
- Dressings - buttermilk, a little mayo, garlic and chives makes a proper ranch-style dip.
- Mash - a splash instead of milk. Aaron took that personally.
Got a scone in one hand? You'll want a mug of proper cocoa in the other.
Oliver would like it noted that he'd put chilli in the dressing. Oliver would put chilli in the scones. Oliver has been asked to leave the dressing alone.
Can you freeze buttermilk?

Yes - buttermilk freezes well for up to 3 months. It separates a bit when it thaws, so whisk it smooth and use it for baking, not drinking.
Freeze it in portions. A tablespoon per hole in lidded silicone trays that stack means you can grab exactly what a recipe needs. Pop the frozen cubes into a labelled bag.
Thaw it in the fridge, never on the side - the Food Standards Agency's chill, freeze and defrost guide has the rules. Keep your fridge at 5C or below.
How long does buttermilk last in the fridge? The lemon-and-milk kind keeps as long as the milk you made it with would - use it within 2 or 3 days. Shop cartons go by the date, and once opened, about a week.
If it smells like cheese, it's no longer buttermilk. It's a decision. Make the right one.
If it goes wrong

It hasn't curdled at all? Not enough acid, or the milk was fridge-cold.
Fix: Check it was a tablespoon, not a teaspoon, and give it another 5 minutes. Even with no specks, it'll still work in baking. A tablespoon is the big one. Ayden knows that now.
It's gone lumpy and cheesy? Too much acid, or it was left far too long.
Fix: Bin it and start again - it only costs a splash of milk. Stick to 1 tbsp per 250ml and 10 minutes. Buttermilk, not cottage cheese. Different post.
Scones came out flat? Over-handled dough, old baking powder, or you twisted the cutter.
Fix: Knead twice, not twenty times, check the date on the baking powder and push the cutter straight down. Treat the dough like a sleeping baby. Don't poke it.
Scones taste of vinegar? You used malt vinegar, or a heavy hand.
Fix: Use lemon juice or white vinegar, and measure it. The bicarb cancels the sourness out in the oven. Erin says scones should taste of jam. Erin is right. Erin is always right.
Dairy-free version is too runny? Plant milks don't thicken like cow's milk.
Fix: Use soya, which curdles best, and hold back 2 tbsp of liquid in the recipe. Runny isn't ruined. It's just relaxed.
The recipe needs more than you made? Ratio panic.
Fix: 1 tbsp acid per 250ml milk, every time. 500ml = 2 tbsp. 125ml = 1½ tsp. Eesha has made a poster. It's on the fridge. It's laminated. Aaron helped.
That's it. Milk, a bit of lemon, ten minutes and no trip to the big Tesco.
And if anyone asks who had the first scone, it was Erin. By royal decree. It's always Erin.
Now go and sour something.






